צום עם אנמיה
Dear Sirs, This letter is concerning the requirement for fasting for myself for all fast days. I recently fasted on the 17th of Tammuz, which
A patient who has a complete C1 paraplegia, in the hospital attatched to machines and has an advance directive stipulating that he does not want to be kept alive. What can be done? More specifically- are family members allowed to carry out his wishes?
Thank you.
DNR in the strict sense of withholding life-saving disease-related measures is not against halakhah. However, there are several qualifications to this lenient position: The patient suffers from an incurable disease and is at a stage where his life expectancy is only a few months; the patient (not his family) is suffering; the patient expresses his wish not to be treated, and if incompetent — there is clear evidence that such were his wishes when he was competent; the treatment is not expected to resolve an immediate complication but rather will incraese the patient's suffering.
The particular case has to be evaluated according to these principles.
Dear Sirs, This letter is concerning the requirement for fasting for myself for all fast days. I recently fasted on the 17th of Tammuz, which
אשתי עולה על טיסה מארה"ב עוד 3 שעות ומעוניינת לדעת מתי עליה להתחיל לצום. תודה!
הרב אוריאל בנר התייחס לשאלה זו בעומק במאמרו, "גדרי מצוות כיבוד אב ואם, והשלכותיהם על טיפול פסיכולוגי" (ספר אסיא י"ב, עמ' 319-325). עיי"ש ובמקורות שהביא.
