שיעורי אנטומיה לכהנים

שתפו:

23 באוקטובר 2018

הרב המשיב: הרב ד"ר מרדכי הלפרין

שאלה:

I am a kohen who has just begun studying medicine. I will be starting anatomy dissections in a couple of months. I was discussing the problem of tuma with a friend who is also a kohen and whose brother is in medical school, and I asked him to find out what heter his brother was relying on. The brother contacted me and said that it was a complicated matter and that I should contact you regarding this. I would greatly appreciate if you would be able to help me solve the dilemma I am currently in. Dissection of bodies is compulsory at my university.

תשובה:

This is a very complicated issue and is perhaps one of the most difficult questions in halakha.

Most posqim have forbidden a kohen to study medicine if he will come into contact with cadavers. However, despite these stringent rulings there are two talmidei hahamim who have permitted studying medicine and anatomy dissections under special conditions.

1. Rabbi Mordekhai ha-Kohen permits a kohen to study medicine and perform dissections on the grounds of piquah nefesh. However, most posqim disagree with this point of view. For example, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein ruled that if a kohen has already graduated as a doctor he might be permitted to take part in certain dissections, but he disagrees with R. ha-Kohen’s ruling that it is allowed because of piquah nefesh. His reasoning is that the principle that one should not desecrate Shabbat to do business in order to raise money which could then be used to save someone’s life applies to someone who wants to break the law in order to study medicine.

2. Rabbi Shlomo Goren permits a kohen to perform dissections under special circumstances: he must wear a special bracelet. However, here, too, many posqim disagreed with this heter.

On a practical level, I don’t know if you are asking whether or not you can continue with your medical career, or if you are asking how you should continue studying medicine with the minimum issurim. If it is the latter case, you should minimize the circumstances of touching a cadaver as much as possible. In Israel, for example, many medical schools allow students to minimize participation in dissections and instead use printed and computerized anatomy atlases for studying anatomy and passing the examinations.

In addition, you should be advised to wear the halakhic bracelet as stipulated by R. Goren.

להדפסה

שאלות נוספות

מה אתם מחפשים?

לורם איפסום דולור סיט אמט, קונסקטורר אדיפיסינג אלית לפרומי בלוף קינץ תתיח לרעח. לת צשחמי צש בליא, מנסוטו צמלח לביקו ננבי, צמוקו בלוקריה.