עיכוב הודעת בדבר מות חולה

שתפו:

23 באוקטובר 2018

הרב המשיב: הרב ד"ר מרדכי הלפרין

שאלה:

Hi there

I wonder if you can help

On Friday I did a ward round and found one of my patients dead. This was very unexpected, there were no warning signs and he had been fine a few minutes before.

I needed to inform the corroner as a post-mortem needs to be done in these cases (I hope this is OK – he was a Goy).

The next thing is I needed to tell his family. the only number I had was of his 80 year old wife whom I had never met. I called her and asked her to come in and see me. She said she was comming in any case with her daughter in a few hours. She became suspicious and asked if her husband was dead. I felt it reasonale to lie in this situatuion and I told her no , but please come in I need to speak to you. I felt that I could not tell her the news over the phone, alone and I was unable to comfort her over the phone or assess the help she needed.

I called her in and told her.

Some of the staff here are upset with me and feel I should have been honest.

What do you feel?

תשובה:

To tell a person about the death of a close family member might be danger.

Therefore the way you handled the case was the right way, both ethically and Halachiclly.

להדפסה

שאלות נוספות

קלי-צום

שלום רב! קשה לי לצום, ולכן לפני צומות אני נוהגת ליטול טבליות קלי-צום. רציתי לוודא שמותר לי ליטלם השנה בשבת – שהרי י"ז בתמוז וט`

קרא עוד »

מה אתם מחפשים?